How to Eliminate Unconscious Bias in Your Hiring Process

WOW Recruitment

Unconscious bias during the recruitment process is one of the key factors preventing organisations from building diverse and inclusive workforces.


Despite the best intentions and supporting policies, employers are at risk of demonstrating discrimination and bias relating to a person’s age, ability, gender, nationality culture or looks.


This can be early on in the process and mean that only a certain profile of candidate even submits an application. Or during face-to-face interactions which either cause the jobseeker to withdraw from the process, resulting in a less-qualified candidate receiving the offer.


In this blog, we explore different ways you can stop unconscious bias in your hiring process and ensure the most worthy candidate is the one offered the job.


Stage 1 – The Job Advertisement


Even before you put your job out into the market, there are several ways you may have already eliminated some jobseekers. The wording of the ad itself, and the supporting job description, can exclude many applicants right off the bat.

Gendered wording is when particular language is used that automatically biases men over women or vice versa. For example, research has shown that phrases like “We are looking for a strong, confident salesperson who can achieve sales targets” appeal more to men and are considered “masculine-coded language”. On the other hand, words such as collaborative, communicative and supportive can appeal more to women. You can use a tool such as the Gender Decoder to check your job description before distributing.


The channels you use to advertise the role can also inform the type of candidate who applies. When deciding where to promote your role, think about who consumes that media – for example, would advertising through some social media channels exclude older applicants?


Stage 2 – The Shortlisting Process


It can be challenging to face a huge pile of CVs on your desk and know that you have to somehow come up with a way to whittle it down. But the criteria you set at this stage is very important and may inadvertently take some candidates out of the running.


Firstly, have a think about the essential skills you’ve listed for the role. Are they really 100% mandatory? Does having a specific qualification or x many years’ experiences truly matter when you could also find a less experienced jobseeker who better fits your team?


Also, it can be a good idea to encourage “blind applications” where CVs are presented without any identifying information such as name, nationality, gender and age. Research studies have shown that after de-identifying CVs, women candidates were significantly more competitive in roles where they are the underrepresented gender. Candidates born overseas or living in lower socio-economic areas were also more competitive.


Many recruitment partners will submit resumes to you in this format anyway, so it’s worth having a chat to them about other ways you can ensure the recruitment process is completely unbiased.


Stage 3 – The Interview


Gone are the days where a job interview was an informal chat with the odd hypothetical question thrown in. Now, structure is essential to ensure an evidence-based, fair outcome that doesn’t alienate any jobseekers.


Your interview should be planned and cover a number of behavioural questions where candidates can demonstrate their previous experience and skills. These responses should all be assessed in a consistent manner against a set of pre-agreed criteria. This doesn’t mean you can’t also include some ice-breaker or motivational questions to better get to know your applicant.


You should also pull together a recruitment panel of peers who can help the assessment process. It is a good idea to ensure there is diversity on the panel, and try to have someone from outside the immediate team to provide an even more impartial perspective.


Finally, try to not make any assumptions based on a candidate’s appearance during the interview process. As long as the applicant is presented neatly and professionally, any judgement about clothing, piercings, tattoos and other physical features must not come into the decision marking.


Stage 4 – The Final Decision


Ultimately, your final decision should be made using metrics rather than your gut. By following the steps above, you should have plenty of information at your disposal including:


  • A shortlisted group of blind applicants who meet all essential criteria and have been sourced from a diverse marketplace
  • A hiring panel of diverse peers who are rating candidates against a consistent scoresheet
  • Reference checks from previous employers who can provide further evidence of the candidate’s capabilities

It’s highly unlikely that you will have a tie at the end of this process, but if this happens it’s okay to consider responses to motivational questions or cultural fit. Just ensure you are able to justify your final decision if questioned.


Summary


Unconscious bias is not only discriminatory and damaging to candidates – it can also mean hiring managers can miss out on the best person for the job due to implicit stereotyping.


Here at WOW Recruitment, our team of specialist recruiters has their fingers on the pulse of the talent marketplace here in Sydney and across Australia. Give us a call today, so we can put you in contact with your next great hire.

By Daniel Tonkin October 3, 2024
In today's rapidly evolving business landscape, customer experience has become more critical than ever. As digital platforms continue to transform the way we interact with brands, businesses must adapt to meet the evolving expectations of their customers. We recently hosted a panel event with industry leaders sharing lessons from their lived experience. We were joined by: Mareile Osthus – Co-Founder & CEO, Humii Blair Redfern – Head of Customer Support, Spaceship Heather Robinson – Customer Care Director, Lyka The Rise of Digital Platforms Traditional customer satisfaction metrics, like Net Promoter Score (NPS), often fall short in providing a comprehensive understanding of the customer journey. Digital platforms, however, offer a wealth of data that can be harnessed to gain deeper insights. This data and feedback on the customer journey should be shared during stakeholder meetings to illuminate pain points and identifying solutions. Companies like Humii are at the forefront of this revolution, using cutting-edge technology to analyse online customer behaviour and identify areas for improvement across the customer’s journey. By combining human analysis with data-driven insights, these platforms provide retailers with actionable recommendations to enhance their customer experience. “You can’t fix what you don’t know or measure.” – Mariele Osthus The Importance of Human-Centricity While technology plays a crucial role in understanding customer behaviour, it's equally important to maintain a human-centric approach. Empathy, personalisation, and a genuine understanding of customer needs are essential for building strong relationships and maintaining brand loyalty. Lyka, a dog food company founded by Anna Podolsky, exemplifies human centricity. By offering customisable plans and using high-quality, human-grade ingredients, Lyka demonstrates a deep commitment to the wellbeing of its customers and their furry friends. Navigating Economic Challenges It’s no surprise the current economic climate presents unique challenges for businesses and their customers. As consumers tighten their belts, it's more important than ever to provide exceptional value and support. Spaceship, a financial services company, is actively addressing these challenges by reducing fees and offering transparent pricing. By prioritising customer needs, providing clear communication and meeting them we’re they’re at financially, Spaceship is building trust and loyalty in a difficult economic environment. “It’s important to get your wider team on the tools to help evolve the CX experience. ” – Blair Redfern The Balancing Act of Technology with Human Touch The successful integration of technology and human touch is essential for delivering an exceptional customer experience. Automation can streamline processes and improve efficiency, but it will never replace human connection. Heather from Lyka emphasises the importance of strategic thinking when it comes to automation. By identifying areas where human touch is most valuable and empathy is needed, businesses can ensure that technology enhances rather than replaces the customer experience. “Define where human touch is needed and automate the other parts.” – Heather Robinson Talent and Culture Attracting and retaining top talent is crucial for delivering exceptional customer experiences. Creating a positive and inclusive work culture is essential for employee engagement and satisfaction. Spaceship has achieved a remarkably low staff turnover by investing in employee wellbeing, offering competitive benefits, and providing opportunities for growth and development. Mariele from Humii emphasises the importance of trust, autonomy, and flexibility in creating a supportive work environment. Emerging Trends and Predictions As the customer experience landscape continues to evolve, businesses must stay ahead of emerging trends. Automation, personalisation, and data-driven insights will play an increasingly important role in shaping the future of customer service. However, it's essential to remember that the human element remains indispensable. By combining technology with empathy and understanding, businesses can build lasting relationships and thrive in the competitive marketplace. Prioritising customer experience and service must be a company-wide mindset. Work-life balance is now the primary driver for employees, closely followed by salary and compensation concerns. Career Development and Job Security remain important factors, while the current unemployment rate stands at 4.2%, reflecting a still-tight job market. Although salaries have seen a slight 4% increase over the past year, growth appears to be slowing. Meet the Speakers Mareile Osthus – Co-Founder & CEO, Humii Humii is a startup that makes retailers’ online customer experience tangible, measurable, and trackable. Mareile, with over 20 years of retail experience and 15 years in e-commerce, has successfully scaled giants like Zalando and THE ICONIC. Her insights on optimising the customer journey were invaluable. Blair Redfern – Head of Customer Support, Spaceship Spaceship is an Australian financial services company dedicated to empowering people to invest in their futures. Prior to joining Spaceship, he gained valuable experience in operations and strategy roles at Plenti and Uber. Heather Robinson – Customer Care Director, Lyka Heather Robinson is the Customer Care Director at Lyka, where she champions the importance of personalised service and human connection in an increasingly tech-driven world. With experience from Menulog and ANZ, she brought a unique blend of expertise in customer care, making her insights particularly impactful. If you're looking to recruit top talent in CX or are a candidate seeking a role in this field, reach out to us! WOW Recruitment specialises in customer experience roles across call centres, operations, business support, and more.
By Emily McLeod, WOW Recruitment September 11, 2024
The best talent in your industry might not be actively searching for a job, but that doesn’t mean they wouldn’t be interested in an opening at your organisation. After all, an opportunity’s an opportunity. This type of candidate search is called ‘passive recruitment’, and it differs pretty heavily from the more well-known ‘active recruitment’. Let’s talk about how they differ, and strategies to attract the best passive talent. Recruiting active vs. passive job candidates Who are active candidates? Active candidates are your classic job seekers. They already know they’re interested in another role, and are actively searching for a new employer. An active recruitment strategy is the common approach: writing job ads, posting them online and vetting candidates who apply. Who are passive candidates? Passive job seekers are candidates who don’t know that they’re candidates. They aren’t actively searching for a new role, and could be quite happy at their current employer. Still, for the right offer they might consider hopping over to your team. A passive recruitment strategy is proactive and slightly more challenging. It’s more of a head-hunting approach, identifying right-fit candidates from across the industry and building relationships with them over time. Many recruiters nurture these relationships even when there are no active job openings, just to stay in people's minds. Then, when a role eventually opens up, half the work is already done. The benefits of recruiting passive candidates Pitching your open role to a passive candidate might seem like a tricky sell, but there are a lot of benefits to finding these talented professionals – often outweighing the extra effort. Gain access to the best talent. Sticking to active recruitment can mean recruiting with blinders on, seeing only the people who are on the hunt. Broadening your search allows you to more accurately target right-fit professionals who you know are highly employable – after all, they are already employed! Reduce time-to-hire. When passive recruitment is done proactively, it may be quicker to fill openings with this strategy; by the time you need someone, you already have a number of prospective candidates sourced and nurtured. Less worker misrepresentation. Taking time to source ideal people ensures you already know a lot about them by the time they come to apply. This can lead to less worker misrepresentation, where people aren’t what their CV says they are. Lower competition. Active job seekers usually apply for multiple jobs at once. Meanwhile, passive job seekers aren’t on the market at all, so you may be the only one talking to them – reducing competition for their skills. Simple strategies to win passive talent 1. Brainstorm your perfect candidate Before starting the passive recruitment process, brainstorm who you actually want to find. This is a goal-setting exercise, giving you a ‘persona’ to target and an objective to measure success against. Some steps to consider: Identify current and future needs within the organisation, to better understand what skills gaps you'll be filling. Ensure you have a complete understanding of the job description, and all the necessary skills and qualifications. Build a persona which outlines the likely demographics, qualifications and other key features of the most likely candidates for any applicable roles. Who they are, where they work, what they know, their preferred salary, industry pain points... all of this may be relevant later. Gain buy-in (and sign-off) from relevant stakeholders within your business, especially whichever team leader is likely to manage this new hire. This will help ensure you’ve got all your details correct. 2. Strengthen your employer brand Your employer brand is your culture, values and mission, value proposition, and reputation. A strong employer brand is instantly recognisable, where professionals in your sector know your business to be a great place to work. The stronger the brand, the wider this reputation spreads. Having a strong employer brand is essential in passive recruitment, as right-fit candidates may engage with your brand long before you ever reach out to them – through your content, social media presence, events presence or word of mouth. If this contact has been positive, they may already have a high opinion of your organisation when you engage them for the first time. Learn more: How to Build an Authentic and Appealing Employer Image 3. Conduct a thorough candidate discovery process Finding right-fit passive candidates goes well beyond job boards. You’re looking for the perfect match, someone to engage and build a relationship with over time, and they might be hanging out in one of a few different places. These are some examples of common sources successful passive recruiters have used in the past to find and engage with the best passive talent. How many are already on your mind? Social media platforms (LinkedIn especially) Industry networking events Relevant online communities (i.e. forums, chat groups and other relevant websites) Industry magazines, blogs and publications, looking for interesting guest writers Company alumni (who can you win back?) Referrals from current employees, industry peers or company alumni Talent from previous hiring initiatives who are still in your database Universities and other relevant colleges, if appropriate for the role The persona(s) you created in step one should help you narrow down your search, and give you a benchmark to measure potential talent against. 4. Reach out and make contact It's most common to reach out to passive candidates via email or social media DM. Of course, if you’re on a mutual online community you might spark up conversation there or introduce yourself at an industry event. Tips to consider when reaching out to passive candidates: Always get to the point. Long-winded introductions are often ignored by busy professionals. Offer a clear value proposition. Focus on value during your pitch. You need to offer something that they don’t have in their current employment, otherwise they won’t see a benefit in jumping ship. We’ll come back to this in point five below. Try to build a rapport. This isn’t a job ad, it’s a blind date. Spark up conversation, keep things moving. This is an ideal opportunity to learn more about the candidate – we'll talk about that below too. Tailor every message. Always tailor your outreach to the platform and person. Mass emails might look like spam. Ask them for a response, even if they aren’t interested. We know they aren’t actively looking for a job, but we can still get a conversation flowing to learn more about them. Alternatively, they might be able to refer you to a trusted colleague who is ready, and who may make a similarly great candidate. 5. Build a relationship with each candidate A good relationship with passive candidates is crucial to earning their trust and, in future, winning their application. This isn't a transactional thing, it’s two people dating, vibing each other out, seeing what the other person is about. Is your opportunity as good as their current one? Is it better? Can they trust you? These are the questions going through their mind. Keep things simple at first, and work your way up You might not pitch an opportunity straight away, instead focusing on dialogue and building the relationship for the relationship’s sake – that’s the proactive part of this we mentioned earlier. Act fast if they show interest Passive candidates can get second thoughts, or waiver and lose interest. Ensure you get them an interview with the right stakeholders as promptly as possible if they show interest, putting some faces to names and offering more of your value proposition to the candidate. Remember, the more you can learn about them the better If you get more information, you might learn more about what they dislike in their current role, or what they’re looking for in a possible new one. This will help you position your company as having the thing that they don’t have, but want. Finally, always respect their time People are busy, and their time is precious. We can empathise with that by keeping things concise, being clear and never pushing someone beyond their comfort level. Even if a candidate is interested, they might not be available yet, and we have to recognise that in order to win them over time. Empathy is never a bad strategy in recruitment! Need help? Call us Passive recruitment can yield excellent results, but it isn’t as simple as active recruitment. That's where you need a dedicated recruitment professional in your corner, helping you with the tricky stuff so you can focus on interviews and choosing the best from the best. To learn more about how we might be able to help with your hiring needs, contact us today .
By Wow Recruitment August 28, 2024
To attract the best people and culture talent to your business, you’ll need to focus on aspects of the role like purpose and value, not just daily tasks.
More Posts